Re: Character Bios [S2]
Posted: Sun Dec 11, 2011 1:27 am
Um... I'm lost.
That was the first reason I didn't talk about this yesterday. The second reason is that NaitoKage brought up wisely that we should avoid arguments here, and I thought maybe this had resolved itself. But if Phoenix wants to leave the game now, I suppose the argument has already come to as bad of a point as it's going to, short of a flame war or something like that, which seems almost impossible.
So I figure I may as well try to understand this now rather than let it fester.
So, like... NK said in another thread that Glowstick might be able to reach 500 mph in robot mode. And Phoenix seems to be saying she never intended for her character to even reach that in robot mode. But then NK also said in this thread that it seemed logical to just go with "swimming" speed for hovering speed, which, according to his presented scales, means Glowstick would hover/fly at a speed of 75 mph. But then Phoenix is insisting that Glowstick is still being purported to be able to go 500 mph. And I can't tell if NaitoKage is affirming or denying that.
And then,
And was Airazor ever shown to have rocket packs in the show? Because she seems to fly fine in robot mode with no obvious means of propulsion.
And then Terrorsaur, while supercharged and in robot mode, still flies slow enough for Cheetor spy on him. But Glowstick's bio says "Glowstick's flight mode isn't as fast as other flight modes, though agile as it's propelled by a directional duct fan." So, yeah, the 500 mph thing doesn't make sense to me either, but I'm not still sure if that's still being said or not.
So I am absolutely lost. Obviously something's wrong- wrong enough for you to want to quit Phoenix. So what is the problem here? I can't really tell who's thinking what anymore.
So Phoenix, if you're still here to talk about this stuff, and if only because I'd hate to see you go while my head's still spinning and wishing I could do something about something I don't understand, could you and NaitoKage both just say in one post what you think your characters' speeds ought to be in robot mode and in beast mode, definitively explain how they're flying that fast, and then explain why you think those speeds are in accordance with the speed stats you've given them?
Or is this all a lot clearer than I've made it out to be?
On one final note about this matter, and with all due respect- because of how confusing I think this has gotten, I think it's unfair to call NaitoKage self-righteous. I don't know him personally, and I suppose since we all have our faults it is technically possible that he's self-righteous just as it's technically possible that Garry Chalk has a serious struggle with emotional engagement or that Scott McNeil has delusions of grandeur, but I'm not seeing it. At least right now. If either of you wish to respectfully show me I'm wrong though...
I just think that NaitoKage is, by nature of having an opinion, continuing to see the issue his way because he has not been persuaded otherwise.
By the way Una, I think almost all of us have done some of the stuff I was talking about on this role play- myself included. (Sonar tried to blow up his ship secretly, and Steelclaw knew he did it just by watching it all happen. Conceivable? I suppose, given Steelclaw's intelligence background. A little too convenient? Eh... yeah.)
And I brought those complaints up because of the times they can become a problem for the story, yes, but I also brought them up because they, at times, render the way we've designed our characters irrelevant.
But it isn't all bad either. Really, it'd be equally terrible if our characters never could guess what was on others' mind, and if our characters could never dodge or survive.
I actually wouldn't mind if everyone stopped telling other characters that they've been wrecked. But I guess at times it's necessary for the speed of the role play.
That was the first reason I didn't talk about this yesterday. The second reason is that NaitoKage brought up wisely that we should avoid arguments here, and I thought maybe this had resolved itself. But if Phoenix wants to leave the game now, I suppose the argument has already come to as bad of a point as it's going to, short of a flame war or something like that, which seems almost impossible.
So I figure I may as well try to understand this now rather than let it fester.
So, like... NK said in another thread that Glowstick might be able to reach 500 mph in robot mode. And Phoenix seems to be saying she never intended for her character to even reach that in robot mode. But then NK also said in this thread that it seemed logical to just go with "swimming" speed for hovering speed, which, according to his presented scales, means Glowstick would hover/fly at a speed of 75 mph. But then Phoenix is insisting that Glowstick is still being purported to be able to go 500 mph. And I can't tell if NaitoKage is affirming or denying that.
And then,
and yet...NaitoKage wrote:Nemesis is in fact faster then Glowstick in robot mode
But if she only flaps her wings in robot mode, why would she be faster in beast mode? And if she was faster flapping her wings in robot mode, it could only be a little faster. And I think I just missed it entirely, but where or in what private conversation did Phoenix say she wanted Nemesis' robot mode flight to only be bird-wing-propelled?NaitoKage wrote:...you didn't want to put some form of propulsion on Nemesis other then flapping her wings in robot mode.
And was Airazor ever shown to have rocket packs in the show? Because she seems to fly fine in robot mode with no obvious means of propulsion.
And then Terrorsaur, while supercharged and in robot mode, still flies slow enough for Cheetor spy on him. But Glowstick's bio says "Glowstick's flight mode isn't as fast as other flight modes, though agile as it's propelled by a directional duct fan." So, yeah, the 500 mph thing doesn't make sense to me either, but I'm not still sure if that's still being said or not.
So I am absolutely lost. Obviously something's wrong- wrong enough for you to want to quit Phoenix. So what is the problem here? I can't really tell who's thinking what anymore.
So Phoenix, if you're still here to talk about this stuff, and if only because I'd hate to see you go while my head's still spinning and wishing I could do something about something I don't understand, could you and NaitoKage both just say in one post what you think your characters' speeds ought to be in robot mode and in beast mode, definitively explain how they're flying that fast, and then explain why you think those speeds are in accordance with the speed stats you've given them?
Or is this all a lot clearer than I've made it out to be?
On one final note about this matter, and with all due respect- because of how confusing I think this has gotten, I think it's unfair to call NaitoKage self-righteous. I don't know him personally, and I suppose since we all have our faults it is technically possible that he's self-righteous just as it's technically possible that Garry Chalk has a serious struggle with emotional engagement or that Scott McNeil has delusions of grandeur, but I'm not seeing it. At least right now. If either of you wish to respectfully show me I'm wrong though...
I just think that NaitoKage is, by nature of having an opinion, continuing to see the issue his way because he has not been persuaded otherwise.
By the way Una, I think almost all of us have done some of the stuff I was talking about on this role play- myself included. (Sonar tried to blow up his ship secretly, and Steelclaw knew he did it just by watching it all happen. Conceivable? I suppose, given Steelclaw's intelligence background. A little too convenient? Eh... yeah.)
And I brought those complaints up because of the times they can become a problem for the story, yes, but I also brought them up because they, at times, render the way we've designed our characters irrelevant.
But it isn't all bad either. Really, it'd be equally terrible if our characters never could guess what was on others' mind, and if our characters could never dodge or survive.
I actually wouldn't mind if everyone stopped telling other characters that they've been wrecked. But I guess at times it's necessary for the speed of the role play.